Designing written submissions to ensure impact and ease judges’ reading

Challenge

Our client, a defendant in a noteworthy litigation case, came to us with a request : transform their counsels’ written submissions in a highly technical litigation to ensure a clear and impactful demonstration of their case. The purpose was to make technical and somewhat tricky digital issues easily accessible to judges, who may not be experts in these fields.

Process

We were involved from the first draft of the written submissions and worked hand in hand with the two renowned law firms representing our client – one specialized in litigation cases and the other in the specific legal field at stake.
Applying user-centricity, we analysed the ways judges approach written submissions. Based on our litigation experience, and user research, it was clear that judges suffer from excessive workload, antisocial working hours, and excessive length of written submissions. “I just can’t read more than 30 pages per party” has become a usual “off-the-record” verbatim.

Before some jurisdictions, there’s even an official limit of number of pages. Thus, our goal was to ease judges’ work by ensuring brevety, giving them “mental oxygen” through cristal-clear information, graphics and overall layouts. We also made the navigation easier between text and supporting exhibits, allowing judges to check evidence more quickly.

Results

An entirely redesigned set of written submissions, with several graphic changes to ease reading and enhance key facts and exhibits. We cannot share the full version but we entirely confidentialized an extract.
We used a clickable Word format, to ensure judges could directly access the relevant exhibits from within the written submissions.

We also used a thread to make sure judges would know how far along they are in their reading, and would easily navigate between the various arguments. Finally, we also made key facts stand out in the layout of the submissions and visualized key complex arguments, to ensure maximum impact.

“I worked with the Amurabi team on a significant litigation case and thier added value enabled us to reinforce our arguments thanks to an impactful layout and in particular thanks to the visualisation of complex facts and key dates”
Benoit Javaux (at the time, counsel at Quinn Emmanuel)

Related work on this topic

ILS NOUS FONT CONFIANCE
orange-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2
dila-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2
renault-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2
ubisoft-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
somfy-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
sncf-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
smu-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
shisheido-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
servier-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
serpentine-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
practical-law-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
mymoneygroup-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
moet-hennessy-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
maif-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
lexis-nexis-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
icc-belgium-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
google-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
geodis-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
euler-hermes-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
editions-legislatives-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
edf-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
delta-capital-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
dalloz-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
cgi-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
airbus-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
enm-logo-amurabi-legal-design-agency-2
logovincinoir-2
logo-carrier4x
logo-cnil4x
logo-hsbc4x
logo-lefebvre4x
logo-sophia4x
logo-total4x
logo-unedic4x
suntory
sciencespo
qonto
ferrero
agencenationalcohesionterritoire
dice-1
roblox-1
bnp-paribas-logo
ILS NOUS FONT CONFIANCE
orange-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2 dila-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2 renault-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x-2 ubisoft-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x somfy-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x sncf-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x smu-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x shisheido-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x servier-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
serpentine-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x practical-law-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x mymoneygroup-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x moet-hennessy-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x maif-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x lexis-nexis-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x icc-belgium-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x google-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x geodis-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x
euler-hermes-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x editions-legislatives-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x edf-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x delta-capital-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x dalloz-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x cgi-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x airbus-client-amurabi-legal-design-agency3x enm-logo-amurabi-legal-design-agency-2 logovincinoir-2
logo-carrier4x logo-cnil4x logo-hsbc4x logo-lefebvre4x logo-sophia4x logo-total4x logo-unedic4x suntory sciencespo
qonto ferrero agencenationalcohesionterritoire dice-1 roblox-1 bnp-paribas-logo

Nous utilisons les rapports fournis par le service Google Analytics – qui transmet des données aux serveurs de Google aux Etats Unis – pour mieux comprendre le trafic et le comportement de nos utilisateurs sur ce site.

Vous pouvez paramétrer ce service, en l’activant ou le désactivant via le bouton ci-dessous.

Pour découvrir notre politique de données personnelles 100% sans jargon, c’est ici !